Zhang Yimou is one of my favourite directors. That makes this film all the
more disappointing. It's a spy thriller that takes place in Manchuria in the
1930's. Four special agents, trained in Russia, are trying to smuggle an
escaped prisoner over the border. There was a notorious Japanese prison, in
which the inmates were tortured. Japan wanted to make a good impression to the
international community, so the prison was demolished and all the inmates were
murdered. Except for one escapee. The special agents want him to testify to
the Japanese atrocities.
My trouble with the film is that I don't really know the characters.
There's very little character development. The male characters are
interchangeable, which is intensified by their identical clothing. I wanted to
sympathise with the female agent who wanted to rescue her children, but she
just isn't interesting enough.
What struck me is how difficult it is to be a spy. There are double agents on
both sides, so nobody knows who he can trust.
The film hasn't been released in England or America. There's a German Blu-ray
which can be watched with German subtitles or dubbing. I recommend the
dubbing, because the subtitles are awkwardly placed, on the bottom edge of the
picture. It makes them difficult to read, especially when snow is lying on the
ground.
Bummer. I hadn't seen Cliff Walkers yet, but it being Zhang Yimou, it was definitely on my list with high expectations. I guess i'll lower them a bit.
ReplyDeleteI gave the film a higher rating (4 stars) the first time I watched it, but I have to be honest: I was being generous to Zhang Yimou as one of my favourite directors. After watching "Cliff Walkers" a second time I had to be honest. It's nowhere near his usual quality.
Delete